A few notes. I've tried to avoid reviews and most previews of the show until I could write down my own thoughts. The Muppets. is done in the format of shows such as The Office, which is a mockumentary. I have never watched The Office nor have I watched most shows of that style. So I am not familiar with the style that the Muppets are taking on here. I am not fond of single camera comedies (basically, no studio audience) in general, though there are some that I like. I think comedies should be performed in front of a live studio audience. I know that any real TV show involving the Muppets cannot be done that way because of the limitations with what the puppets can actually do and the involvement of the performers (though they have done occasional live shows). The original Muppet Show had a laugh track and a staged studio audience (involving more Muppets).
I am going to try to use time codes within the playing of the show. These time codes are based on the viewing of the show on the Watch ABC app.
00:20 Nice to include the old Muppet Show theme in the new show's intro.
01:10 Some jokes recycled from the 10 minute pitch. That just seems weird.
01:45 The Zoot AA joke was good. I've heard it's that type of humor.
02:45 Not a fan of the Muppets being in on the behind the scenes documentary. Or Gonzo's joke about it.
04:00 Miss Piggy is a bitch. I think this is an over-the-top version of herself for the show. It might be too much.
n/a In some ways, this feels like a modern-day version of the old Muppet Show.
05:13 that cue card joke is funny, but makes Fozzie look stupid for not knowing what he's supposed to say every night on Up Late With Miss Piggy.
05:55 the "bacon-wrapped hell on Earth" joke was kind of funny and kind of weird to hear from Kermit The Frog in the 10 minute pitch pilot, but played out better here with Sam Eagle saying "you can't say hell".
06:35 The Tom Bergeron line with Kermit yelling to Scooter is funny.
06:52 Fozzie driving a car!!!
07:10 Fozzie at dinner with his girlfriend's parents is kind of awkward for this being a pilot episode. I just think they should be introducing the characters a little more. It seems like this is just a joke setup.
08:10 I'm mixed on "Dancing with the Czars". But it's classic Gonzo.
08:45 I don't like the Denise character. Very bad first introduction.
08:47 Kermit said "God" (in "God knows"). Weird.
09:25 a full-sized Fozzie puppet is still weird to see. Acceptable, but weird.
10:07 Miss Piggy working out. She doesn't seem like the person to do that.
10:22 "Is this the guy in the hat" doesn't land for me unless you saw the 10 minute pilot.
11:38 I really don't like Denise. Sexy southern accent. I never believed Kermit and Piggy as a real couple, so their breakup crossed into new territory for me. And so does Denise being "with" Kermit.
11:55 More Rizzo! He's under-used.
12:15 Kermit making an executive decision seems a bit assertive for his character. I don't think he ever put his foot down like that on the original show. It was usually more chaos, which was always better comedy.
13:06 Scooter's joke about the "subtle look" was awful.
13:40 Great camera work on the golf cart scene. Also with Scooter being thrown from it.
14:54 Animal's subtle joke about being a woman's man seems out of place but funny.
15:03 Nothing against Imagine Dragons, or Elizabeth Banks for that matter, but I'm not a fan of random celebrity guest stars on TV shows. Yes, the original Muppet Show and even Muppets Tonight in the same format had a guest host, but that's different. I mean stars showing up on the show because they're stars. I've heard this new show will have that every week. The basic premise that Miss Piggy hosts a talk show is just a convenience mechanism for the guest stars. In a lot of cases, I don't see what it adds to the show and to the comedy. Even worse would be most of these celebrity hits and talk show appearances being sneaky promos for other ABC shows. In this one, Elizabeth Banks at least adds a little bit to the story line, but I don't see what Imagine Dragons brings to the show.
15:12 Finally some real chaos. There's comedy in that, right?
15:38 Fozzie seems a bit desperate to impress his girlfriend's parents. His desperation should only be in his comedy.
16:19 Uncle Deadly cameo appearance brushing down Kermit ("skin! skin!") might have been the first time I laughed out loud in my second viewing of the show. But I also don't remember that joke the first time.
16:40 This Kermit-Piggy fight seems so wrong. So does their breakup. There was already great tension in their 40 year relationship.
17:15 I still don't understand why it's Kermit's fault that he didn't know about the tension between Miss Piggy and Elizabeth Banks from the breakup scene.
18:43 The camera work in this scene with Kermit and Piggy in her dressing room makes me a bit queasy.
19:30 The joke about Kermit's stomach seems unnatural for The Muppets.
19:54 Miss Piggy as a talk show host (on the air) makes me think of the late Joan Rivers. I hope that's intentional, especially given their "history".
20:00 Having Imagine Dragons playing somewhat justifies having them on the show, and it shows off some puppetry and camera work, but it takes time away from the clever writing I was promised.
21:00 Okay, Animal going missing in the drum is sort of that joke.
I hope the writing improves once they finish establishing all of the characters in these new roles. I expect more of the "pilot" stuff in episode 2. Like where was Rowlf? Given how the Muppets as a general concept grew in the 1960s doing commercials, I would love to see them doing real or mock commercials during some of the advertising time. The video runs a total of 21 minutes, 21 seconds, in a 30 minute timeslot. I'm sure it's normal, but it seems a bit short to me.
For good measure, here are some of my original thoughts from watching (ultimately on DVR) Tuesday night after the I saw premiere for the first time. These came from my twitter feed.
okay. for me, the jury is still out on #TheMuppets. that said, it's a lot better than most other sitcoms on TV. I do want to watch it again.
— Jason Bornstein (@DyHrdMET) September 23, 2015...there were jokes that I laughed out loud at. some thinking humor (some of which I read about and already got). it was a different show...
...I'm just not used to watching those single-camera fast-paced shows like The Office, which #TheMuppets is. so maybe that's on me.
other thoughts on #TheMuppets - I think I noticed more tonight how much of a real couple they were with their scripted breakup than ever b4.
...meaning, in all other #TheMuppets movies and shows, they never looked like a couple. maybe a bit in the 2011 movie. different tonight.
...it feels like there's still more about the show for us to learn in the coming episodes. so that will be fun. #TheMuppets
there was 1 moment early in the show where I did think Jim Henson would approve. I really hope so. that legacy feels important. #TheMuppets
I'm a little disappointed but not 100% surprised in what I saw. I was a bit underwhelmed. It's new for the Muppets to be in the real world, and I hope I can (and get the time) to adjust to it. Despite the grade of C+/B-, I'm going to continue watching the show. It's The Muppets. I would continue watching unless I was truly offended. Other shows with this grade, however, I wouldn't.
